Say Cheese Pizza: A Flavorful Journey in Mt Shasta
Say Cheese Pizza, located at 304 Maple St in Mt. Shasta, CA, is a beloved pizzeria known for its exceptional offerings and inviting atmosphere. Customers rave about the outstanding crust, non-greasy pizzas, and a unique salad bar that elevates the dining experience. Highlights include a variety of pizzas, including a flavorful veggie option, and distinct side dishes like garlic bread with a unique twist. The friendly staff and nostalgic decor contribute to its charm, making it a must-visit spot for families and groups. Despite occasional waits, the quality of the food and the warm ambiance make every visit worthwhile.
Photos & Gallery
Say Cheese Pizza: Reviews & Ratings
Best crust, usually don’t eat the crust but it was so good and not greasy. They had a nitro on tap that was amazing and the best was the salad bar!! The bald guy behind the counter was great! A must stop.
I am vegetarian and We tried: 1. Veggie pizza - it was good 4/5 2. Garlic bread - it was really different from other garlic bread I have tried ( sour and fermented taste) 4/5 3. Curly fries- it was okay 3/5 Overall, good place for a meal.
Say Cheese pizza was the hottest ticket I’ve ever seen on a Saturday night in July. We called ahead and ordered an hour in advance. Our pizza was ready when we arrived because the kitchen thought we had asked it to go, otherwise they wait until you check in to bake the pizza. There may be long waits, but the food is very good and worth the wait if you’re looking for a good meal. We had 26 people in our overall group, and though it was busy we found places to all sit at 7:30. Some room had a reserved sign from earlier, so consider that if you’ve got a big group. Overall we were glad to come here for our dinner all together and we’ll be back if we visit Shasta again!
Really good pizza, staff is friendly. Atmosphere is similar to what I remember from an old childhood pizza place. Wood panels, simple tables and chairs, a few TVs with sports on. Brought my kids here last august and it was certainly a hit.
Devastated to learn that my hometown pizzeria, say cheese is closing for good. I have had like minded “New York” style pizza all around the world, and I can truly say, Say cheese is one of the best. With that said, the inside needs an entire overhaul. Hopefully the new owners know know what they are doing. I’m vary familiar with the chain pizzeria that is coming in. I hope they can even remotely replicate the taste and quality Say Cheese has offered over the years.
Excellent veggie pizza...seemed a salad pizza. Next time will ask for less olives. Salad was good. But almost empty at 8ish pm. The salad bar needs to be more cleaner as saw the meat parts in some of salads. Keep it up!
Say cheese is hands down the best pizza ive ever had. The family who owned this place is absolutely amazing and there will never be another place like this the way they care for their food and their customers is like none other. This place will truly be missed but thank you the Steve and Lori for providing such an amazing service to our community
Great Food Experience our group ordered Veggie 14’ Pizza Veggie Hot Sandwich Fries Lemonade The ambience is decent. Good amount of seating. The Service is super slow, I guess it’s a family operated restaurant and not taking off any points for the slow service as today there was fires near Mt Shasta and some benefit of doubt that they were not fully staffed Now the important part TASTE : all in our group felt that it tasted AWESOME!!!!! If you are a vegetarian and near Mt Shasta do try the above items mentioned you shall not be disappointed. They did mess up our order (fries ) a bit but were prompt to bring it to us when we informed.
Location
-
304 Maple St, Mt Shasta, CA 96067, United States Hotline: +1 530-926-2821
Welcome to Say Cheese Pizza, a beloved gem located at 304 Maple St, Mt Shasta, CA. Renowned for its exceptional New York-style pizza, this charming eatery has carved a niche in the hearts of locals and visitors alike. If you're stopping by, you can reach them at +1 530-926-2821.
Say Cheese Pizza is not just about pizza; it’s an experience filled with deliciousness and warmth. Customers rave about their signature crust, often remarking that it's the best they've ever had—light, flavorful, and surprisingly not greasy. Mary Miller sums it up perfectly, declaring it a "must stop" for everyone who enjoys tasty pizza. Paired with a refreshing nitro on tap and a salad bar that’s a delightful surprise, the culinary offerings here do not disappoint.
Vegetarian options are equally commendable, with dishes like the veggie pizza praised by diners such as Sonali Tyagi, who found its flavors strikingly fresh. The garlic bread, with its unique fermented taste, sets it apart from the typical fare, making every bite an adventure. And although the curly fries received mixed reviews, the overall sentiment highlights an earnest effort to cater to diverse palates.
Say Cheese Pizza comes alive on those bustling Saturday nights, welcoming large parties with open arms. As shared by Meadow Pritchett, even with a group of 26, they found camaraderie and comfort, all while enjoying the mouthwatering offerings that emerged from the kitchen. Although there may be waits during peak times, the general consensus is that the quality of food makes every moment spent waiting utterly worthwhile.
The ambiance at Say Cheese is reminiscent of classic pizza parlors, with wood panels and simple decor that invokes nostalgia. As Michael Zanghi reflects, it’s a family-friendly environment where great memories are made, especially for those sharing a slice with loved ones. Although challenges lie ahead with changes in ownership, the essence of Say Cheese remains vibrant in the hearts of its dedicated patrons.
In a world where food is often fast and fleeting, Say Cheese Pizza stands as a testament to the art of pizza-making and community gathering. Whether you're a local or just passing through Mt Shasta, make sure to indulge in their renowned pies and soak in the warm atmosphere—it’s an experience you won’t soon forget!
- Accessibility
- Has wheelchair-accessible car park
- Has wheelchair-accessible seating
- Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
- Service options
- Serves dine-in
- Payments
- Accepts debit cards
- Accepts NFC mobile payments
- Credit cards